Signal Blocks Siri AI and Gemini From Reading Chats on Phones
On November 20, Signal said it is restricting the AI agents built into mobile operating systems from capturing its chats. On iOS 27 the app prevents screenshots, with a Block Siri AI setting. On Android it switches on Screen security when it detects an AI assistant reading the screen. macOS is not covered, and Signal calls the remedy incomplete.
On this page
Signal treats the operating system as the new threat
Signal published a post by its president, Meredith Whittaker, on November 20 saying the app is now restricting the latest AI agents built into mobile operating systems from capturing and storing Signal data. Reuters, which saw the post before it went live, reported the change the same day.
The argument is simple. Apple's Siri AI, with its onscreen awareness feature, and Google's Gemini on Android can look at whatever an app displays. Once an agent scans the screen, the content becomes available to whichever local database or remote server that agent uses. Signal's encryption protects messages in transit, but it cannot protect text that the operating system itself reads after decryption. Whittaker's post calls this "an existential threat to Signal."
There is a precedent. Last year Signal blocked screenshots by default on Windows 11 to keep Microsoft Recall from capturing chats. Signal describes Recall as taking screen captures every few seconds, running text recognition on them, and building a searchable database on the device, which could have kept Signal content, including disappearing messages, indefinitely.
What changes on iPhone, Android and Mac
The protections differ by platform because the platforms give Signal different tools:
- iOS 27: Signal prevents screenshots inside the app. A screenshot in Signal's post shows the control labelled "Block Siri AI."
- Android: Signal says it cannot reliably detect screenshot attempts on many manufacturer builds. Instead, it detects when an AI assistant tries to read the screen and then automatically enables its existing "Screen security" setting.
- macOS: Signal is not blocking Siri AI on the Mac, because it says screenshot blocking cannot be done reliably there. Its only advice for macOS 27 is to add Signal to Excluded Apps under System Settings, then Siri.
Reuters reports that the mobile restrictions are switched on by default and that users see a pop-up offering to disable the block when Signal detects a screenshot attempt or an assistant trying to read the screen, depending on the device. Signal's own post confirms that users can turn the protections off in settings, at a privacy cost, but does not describe the pop-ups.
The per-app exclusion Signal points Mac users to is recent. The Electronic Frontier Foundation noted in October that Apple had added a way to exclude individual apps from Siri AI, replacing a set of scattered toggles, while warning that onscreen awareness was still something users and developers could not fully control.
Signal says its own fix is incomplete
Signal is unusually direct about the limits. Blocking screenshots does nothing about other routes, such as an agent reading data already stored on the device through the filesystem. The Android approach will not work on every device. The Mac is uncovered. And Signal says it had to do its own forensic work on iOS and Android because the platforms document so little about how their agents behave.
So the post is also a request. Signal asks Apple, Google and Microsoft for a well documented way for developers to opt out of AI data access, covering screen reading, filesystem access, notifications and APIs, without breaking the app's core function. It also wants technical specifications for how agents collect and process data, and says confidential computing alone is not a full answer. Signal describes itself as cautiously optimistic that Apple and Google are engaging.
Third-party agents are a separate problem. Signal names Meta's Muse as an agent that relies on accessibility settings. Reuters reported earlier in the week that Muse reached Signal messages on a Mac and an Android phone through permissions granted at setup, without using Meta's own Connector tool. According to Reuters, an Apple update this week closed that specific pathway and added new permissions and warnings for agents, while Meta said Muse only accesses other apps through permissions users explicitly grant.
Why one app cannot solve this alone
The useful lesson here is about where privacy boundaries actually sit. An encrypted messenger controls its protocol and its code. It does not control the screen, the notification system, or the disk. When the operating system ships an assistant that can see all three, every private app is reduced to asking for exemptions one release at a time.
That is why Signal's request for a developer opt-out matters beyond Signal. Banking apps, health apps, password managers and local AI tools that keep data on the device all face the same exposure. A blocked screenshot is a blunt tool: it also stops the user from capturing their own conversation.
Until platforms offer something better, the practical steps are modest. Update Signal, leave the new protections on, and on a Mac add Signal to the Siri excluded apps list. Then review which assistants and third-party agents hold accessibility, notification or screen recording permissions on each device, and remove any that do not need them.